Monday, March 19, 2012

Assessment Trough the Student's Eyes

I do think that through teacher’s assessments they have produced winners and losers in their classrooms. And I think it is very dangerous feeling like a loser at a young age. This could cause kids to fall farther behind and quickly lose all hope in themselves and their abilities to succeed. Today schools are more focused on helping all students succeed in meeting standards. We need a new form of assessment that can make them more confident and motivate them so their learning potential grows. The article suggests that we need to tune into the emotional dynamics of the assessment experience from the students point of view, both losers and winners. This is a great idea that I could see really working. I think students would also benefit from teachers sharing their achievement targets and expectations with them. Students also need descriptive feedback in manageable amounts. Teachers and students need to be partners in the learning assessment process. And with feedback students should start to develop personal goals for themselves. I liked how the article said when students become self-assessors they start to see that success is within their reach if they keep trying. I also think it is a great idea to have the students sit down and look at the rubric and even see examples of what the teacher is looking for. I think this would also really benefit the students. I hope schools can get to a point where they are producing winning streaks for all students.

4 comments:

  1. Well said! This whole idea of students on a losing streak at a young age can set the tone for their entire school career. I've noticed that the students I have tutored in the past have one trait in common. When working through math problems, since that is my area, the students are never confident in their abilities. Often times they stop working until I say they are doing it right and then they'll continue. I wonder if this behavior comes from the fact that so many times in the past they have been wrong that they are afraid to try now. It is so unfortunate that these kids have the potential but are now afraid to try. We need to get them on a winning streak again and show them that if they keep trying, they will succeed.

    I like the idea of letting students see a rubric and allow them to see where they may go wrong in a problem and why they don't understand something. This is more beneficial than the students getting discouraged over and over again because they didn't do well and not changing anything after. I love the way you put this idea, "descriptive feedback in manageable amounts." That's right because the kids might get overwhelmed if we throw too much advice and feedback at them, and it may have the opposite effect.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really like what you had to say, Katie. You brought up a lot of good points that are key points of this article. I definitely think it is important to get kids on a winning streak at a young age. Kids are so impressionable. If we help them to believe that they are capable of anything from a young age, they are likely to keep believing it.
      I loved what you had to say, too, about using descriptive feedback in manageable amounts. Both parts of that are so important. The feedback we give has to be descriptive. It has to help our students improve, not just tell them what they are doing wrong. I also think it is important to do in manageable amounts. If we give our students lots to work on, but don't help them through it, it isn't going to be beneficial, regardless of how descriptive it is.

      Delete
  2. I also talked about having the students create their own rubric to better thier learning as well. I think by doing that they are far more like to meet the requirements needed. I also like what you said about "descriptive feedback." There is a differance between feedback and descriptive feedback. The more details you are able to go into the better.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes Christy I agree! It would be a great idea for students to create their own rubric. Ii like how this involves them in the assessment process. I think this would also help them to meet the requirements needed. Also feedback is so important and really helps the students see what they need to fix and what they did great on! Good post!

    ReplyDelete